15 Best Muffin Pan Reviews in 2021 You Don’t Wanna Miss

I love muffins. They’re delicious, easy to make and come in a variety of flavors. The only problem is that muffin pans can be hard to find! I set out on a mission to find the best muffin pan for my needs by conducting a thorough review process with 11 products. In this article, I will share my findings with you so that you can buy the perfect product for your kitchen too!

Muffin Pan vs Cupcake Pan

A cupcake pan is an oblong baking tin with anywhere from 6 to 12 cups for holding small amounts of liquid batter. They are similar in shape to muffin pans, but cupcakes tend to be slightly larger and less rounded than muffins.

A muffin pan is a cooking pan designed to make muffins. It consists of cups that are greased or coated with butter to prevent sticking, and they come in different sizes, such as mini-muffin pans (also called jumbo), which yield very small muffins, standard size which is slightly larger than a cupcake pan’s muffin cups, and the jumbo muffin pan.

The difference between a cupcake pan and a muffin pan is that a cupcake pan has fewer cups for batter due to the bigger size of each individual cup, while the cups are smaller on the muffin pan.

On the other hand, it takes less time to bake because of its bigger sizes, although you will need to watch it more closely. A cupcake pan is typically smaller than a muffin pan, but more fat will be needed because the size of each cupcake is bigger.

Finally, cupcakes are rounder and flatter than muffins which are usually dome-shaped; also, they have a hole in the middle while muffins don’t.

List of 15 Best Muffin Pan Reviews

1. Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Bakeware Standard Muffin Pan

This Wilton non-stick baking pan is the perfect size for every occasion. With a bakeware standard muffin pan, you’ll be able to whip up batches of quick desserts for friends and family members in no time.

Made from durable steel that resists warping, this pan promises even results every time. The non-stick surface ensures your dishes will come out easily and can go right into the dishwasher after use – just remember to wash it before first use.

A perfectly measured 2-inch opening allows for precise positioning when slicing leftover goodies, while its size ensures that your dishes are uniformly cooked throughout every inch of their surface area. Consider this classic addition to any kitchen essential list today.

2. SILIVO Silicone Muffin Pans Nonstick 12 Cup

Serve up fun, creative baked goods for friends and family in these SILIVO Silicone Muffin Pan – perfect for everyday baking needs. Fill the cups with your favorite muffin or cake recipes, bake to perfection, and enjoy dessert time.

No more messy pans trying to remove your desserts from their paper liners. The silicone pan’s flexible design allows you to easily take out all 12 of your goodies while keeping them inside their individual containers.

This 12-cup silicone muffin pan is perfect for baking. It will release your creations easily, and it can handle 450 degrees Fahrenheit in the oven.

Plus, these muffin pans are super easy to wash- simply pop them right into the dishwasher, oven, microwave, or freezer. This versatile pan suits any menu need while making cleaning a breeze – it’s worth every single penny.

3. USA Pan Bakeware Cupcake and Muffin Pan

USA Pan Muffin pan is a handy tool for every baker’s arsenal! It’s made in the USA using quality materials that won’t break down over time. This bakeware provides a quick release, easy cleanup, and features Americoat coating, which promotes fast and easy cake release–plus minimal baking hassle.

The aluminized steel muffin pan includes twelve cups with measurements from 1 3/8 to 2 3/4 inches deep–so you can fill them perfectly every single time. Perfectly sized to fit any occasion or appetite, this model is everything a baker needs without the high prices.

4. Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick 6 Cup Jumbo Muffin Pan

This two-pack of Wilton Jumbo Muffin Pans will give you all the space and flexibility you need to whip up a delicious dessert or savory meal for your family.

Heavy-gauge construction ensures even baking without warping or cracking in your favorite recipe. Dishwasher safe – so you only have one dish to wash after a big batch of your most loved indulgences.

You can also bake jumbo cupcakes, savory egg cups, and more with the comfort that the non-stick surface will release them quickly and cleanly. So, this is one of the best muffin pans for eggs.

They want to make sure the customers are completely satisfied with this product, so they included a limited 5-year warranty on these jumbo muffin pans.

5. Amazon Basics Nonstick Muffin Baking Pan

You’ll find this baking pan to be the perfect companion for all your muffin (or cupcake) needs. Measuring 13.9 x 10.6 x 1.2 inches, these two nonstick muffin pans are each equipped with 12 cups–plenty of space to get started on your next batch of delicious treats.

Made from hearty steel, the durable construction helps ensure that you can bake away worry-free–no more burnt or over browned muffins slipping off into the oven. It’s dishwasher safe and ovenproof up to 500°F for clean baking every time.

What’s more, is that the Muffin pan comes in a set of 2, so you can put one in reserve so your other nonstick baking dish won’t get worn out any time soon.

6. CAKETIME 12 Cups Silicone Muffin Pan

Did you know that CAKE TIME 12 Cup Flexible Silicone Muffin Pan can be used to make a wider array of foods? There’s no need for an additional pan. This muffin pan is made from food-grade silicone, making it heat resistant from -104 degrees Fahrenheit all the way up to 446 degrees Fahrenheit.

In the box, there are 12 cups that measure 2.75″ in diameter and 1.1″ deep that fit into this professional-grade molding tray like dominoes. The nonstick surface on each cup ensures easy release and easy clean-up. You’ll love using the wide-size muffin pans for baking your goods quickly with consistent results every time.

7. OvenStuff Non-Stick 6 Cup Jumbo Muffin Pan

Give your muffins the attention they deserve with this nonstick 6-cup oven-safe Muffin pan. The extra-large 12.7″ by 8.7″ space provides plenty of room for your most indulgent ideas; it’s perfect not only for baked goods but also heavier sauces or pasta dishes which require more elbow grease to stir and toss.

For everyday use, cleanup is a breeze thanks to our nonstick coating, which eliminates sticking and prevents any baking disasters in its tracks.

Constructed from durable steel that heats evenly without hot spots, this muffin pan will deliver beautiful golden results every time – no matter how you like them: simple and sweet with fruit accompaniments, savory like brunch favorite French toast, or decadently.

8. Tiawudi 3 Pack Nonstick Muffin Pan

Tiawudi 3-pack nonstick muffin pans are made from heavy-weight carbon steel and have a food-safe coating. The pan is oven-safe to 450 degrees F for quick, even bake times. At the same time, the nonstick coating ensures easy release of your food with minimal sticking – perfect for baking rich chocolate brownies or making mini cheesecakes in just minutes.

The set includes three muffin pans, each with 6 cups channels that give you a total of 18 cups to create a variety of dishes – perfect for entertaining.

Lightweight, nonstick muffin pans with high-quality materials to guarantee ease of use and longer lifespan. It has versatile dimensions that are great for baked goods. If you’re looking for a set of three baking pans, look no further than these. This product comes with a lifetime guarantee – We know the pan will last.

9. Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick 6-Cup Standard Muffin Pan

Not all of us are born cooking geniuses, but with the Wilton 6-Cup Standard Muffin Pan, we can still whip up a quick batch of morning muffins and leave them on the counter as an early surprise for breakfast.

Equipped with easy handles that make it easier to pull out of the oven and slim seams that help evenly distribute heat and prevent warping, this pan is ready for any muffin recipe—decadent French toast or savory cornbread.

As an added bonus, the nonstick coating is made from high-quality materials, so you won’t have to worry about your eggs dripping through the bottom. The six included cups come in handy when baking springtime’s favorite treat.

With a dishwasher-safe design, it’s easy to clean up anytime after baking by popping them into your dishwasher or hand washing in warm soapy water before first use, and after each time you cook with this muffin pan.

10. Rachael Ray Yum -o! Nonstick Bakeware 6-Cup Muffin Tin

Rachael Ray Nonstick Muffin Pan is the perfect companion to your baking traditions. With easy clean-up and durable nonstick, this truly is cooking made simple. It’s oven safe to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, so you can bake anything that makes your mouth water just by opening up a cookbook.

The long-lasting nonstick interior and exterior make it easier than ever to prepare low-fat treats that can be popped into the oven or microwave for quick meal solutions when time is scarce.

The even heat distribution permits you to bake cookies, cake pops, or place cupcakes in liners that are perfect for parties or celebrations of any kind without them ceasing halfway through baking.

11. CHEFMADE Muffin Cake Pan

This CHEFMADE muffin pan may be a solution for you if you have past experiences with underbaked muffins or muffins that were too dry. The muffin pan is made from commercial-grade carbon steel for even baking results. Its thickness of 0.8 millimeters also contributes to even baking. The silicone coating, which is food-grade, allows for the easy release of baked muffins. It also doesn’t contain PFOA and PTFE chemicals.

To prevent warping, the edges of this pan have been reinforced. This pan bakes quickly due to its thick carbon steel. You can make muffins quicker and save energy.

12. Anolon Advanced Nonstick 12-Cup Muffin Tin With Silicone Grips and Lid

Although the Anolon Advanced Muffin Pan may be expensive, you will immediately notice that it is a high-quality product. The pan is heavy-duty and has silicone grips at the ends that make it easy to hold.

It turned out perfect for everything we baked. We were pleased to find that the muffins and popovers had dark crusts.

The manufacturer suggests hand washing the muffin pan, but its nonstick finish makes cleaning it simple.

13. All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Muffin Pan

It might be very plain in appearance. All-Clad’s muffin pan does all you could ask for and more. This muffin pan is made of commercial-grade aluminized steel that will keep your baked goods warm and safe even if you leave them at 450 degrees Fahrenheit without worrying about burning.

It also features a non-stick, ceramic-reinforced finish that can ensure nothing remains after baking. The buttery texture makes it easy to hold and maneuver in tight spaces.

14. Silpat Perfect Non-Stick Muffin Mold

Silpat is a well-known brand for making high-quality nonstick baking mats. It is also known for its excellent silicone muffin pans. Silpat’s muffin pan is made from a unique textile fiberglass core covered in food-grade silicone. It’s flexible and heat-resistant to 500°F, just like other Silpat products. It is also dishwasher, freezer, and microwave safe.

It is silicone-based, so you can pop out muffins and cupcakes easily from the wells. Also, cleaning up is easy. Silicone doesn’t stick as hard to muffin and cupcake crumbs as metal does.

A silicone muffin pan has one drawback. It’s too floppy, so it can be difficult to pop it in the oven with uncooked batter. To transport the pan, we recommend placing it on an oven rack.

15. Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Nonstick Bakeware 6-Cup Jumbo Muffin Pan

This muffin pan is simple and well-made. It can bake six muffins or cupcakes. The nonstick aluminum-steel construction ensures that you can bake larger than standard jumbo muffins at the right temperature.

It is heavy enough not to warp, and it can be washed in the dishwasher after each use. This is the best choice for jumbo baking muffins. They can sometimes brown too quickly and not cook through the middle.

How To Choose The Best Muffin Pan

The ideal muffin pan for you may depend on your budget, the type of cake or bread you typically make, and how many servings you typically need.

For example, if you are baking a lot of mini-sized cupcakes at once, then an aluminum muffin pan with 12 cups is perfect. But if your preference is to bake one large loaf of bread at a time, then it would be better to get an oblong pan that will accommodate this size without spilling over into another section.

Below are some tips to help narrow down the choices: This guide provides information on how to choose the best muffin pan, so there’s never any confusion when shopping for one again!

Size

Consider how many people your muffin quiches will be baked for. This will affect how many cups of muffin batter you need. A smaller, more affordable 6 cup muffin tray might be sufficient if you are just cooking for yourself. If you are cooking for your whole family, however, you may want to invest in the 12- or 16-cup muffin pans.

Mini cups are a great option if you plan to make these for your children. To make the best buying decision, consider your personal circumstances before you buy the first muffin pan that you see.

Depth

Even with standard-sized muffin pans, the depth of the cup may vary. A standard-sized muffin tray will have a depth of approximately 1 inch. The depth of deeper pans will be closer to 1.5 inches. Muffin pans with a muffin top will be less than one inch deep.

Material

  • Coated steel: Steel can be strong and affordable material. For quick release of baked goods, muffin pans made from steel are coated in a nonstick substance such as silicone or Teflon. Steel pans are susceptible to rusting and can lose their coating over time.
  • Stainless steel: These are the classic muffin “tins.” Steel’s durability makes them resistant to rusting and scratching.
  • Aluminum: This is the most common material for muffin pans. Lightweight aluminum conducts heat well, resulting in evenly baked muffins. We recommend choosing thicker aluminum to avoid developing holes over time.
  • Silicone: This flexible, lightweight plastic material feels almost like rubber. It can also be baked at 500 degrees F. Silicone muffin pans don’t need a nonstick coating because you can invert the cups to pop your muffins out once they are cooled.

Grips and Handles

Grips and handles allow you to hold onto a muffin pan securely when it is being placed in or taken out of the oven. These features will prevent you from spilling batter or dropping it while using bulky oven mitts to remove it. For those with arthritis, stiffness, or pain in the hands or wrists, grips and handles can make baking more simple.

Nonstick Coating Types

A muffin pan that has a nonstick coating is the best. It allows for food to be released and preserves your muffins during removal. Nonstick coatings can be used to replace paper liners or individually grease muffin cups.

  • Teflon: Also called polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), this is a slippery coating that is used in metal pans. Teflon will begin to break down at 500 degrees F, so do not use it higher than that.
  • Ceramic: A thin layer of ceramic is another nonstick material that can be used to protect metal pans. This non-toxic, eco-friendly option is also available. It can become worn over time and is expensive.
  • Superhydrophobic: This is a new type of coating that’s water-repellent. This prevents your muffins from sticking to the pan. It is made of different nanomaterials.

Price

Prices for muffin pans vary from $10 to $25. A nonstick pan made of steel will not last long and cost less than $10. You can buy silicone muffin pans or pans with side grips for $10-15. Prices for aluminum pans and ceramic-coated pans range from $15 to $20. You can expect to pay up to $25 for top-of-the-line cast-iron and stainless steel pans.

10 Ways to Use a Muffin Tin That’s Sitting In Your Cabinet

Conclusion

The search for the perfect muffin pan is finally over! I hope that my findings have been helpful to you and your quest in finding a great product. If not, don’t worry–I’ll be continuing this blog post in an upcoming article with more reviews of other products on the market, so stay tuned! For now, though, click here to buy the best muffin pan from Amazon today.

Leave a Comment